your solar quotes solar news blog renewable energy target

Disgraceful new RET proposal is economic vandalism

Disgraceful new renewable energy target proposal to destroy future of renewable energy in Australia and drive up power bills.

A new proposal by federal senator David Leyonhjelm would destroy the future of renewable energy in Australia while driving up power prices, the Clean Energy Council said today. Clean Energy Council Acting Chief Executive Kane Thornton said the cynical and dangerous proposal showed a fundamental disrespect for the livelihoods of 21,000 workers in the renewable energy industry – as well as the 80 per cent of Australians that want more renewable energy.

“The proposal seeks to reward all existing hydro generation through the Renewable Energy Target (RET) at the expense of investment in newer types of renewable generation such as large-scale solar, marine and geothermal power,” Mr Thornton said.

“This proposal would lead to a wealth transfer of more than $900 million a year, or $13.5 billion between now and 2030, paid to existing hydro power at the expense of much of the planned $14.5 billion of investment in new large-scale renewable energy.

**“As well as reducing new investment, this wealth transfer would lead to higher power bills for consumers in the future. Less competition in the energy market and greater reliance on gas for electricity would increase power bills, something that has been shown by multiple studies this year.

“While clearly hydro power is an important part of Australia's energy mix and continues to be the major source of zero emission renewable electricity in Australia, this proposal is at odds with the fundamental intent of the RET to attract additional investment in renewable energy,” he said.

A summary of the flaws in this proposal includes:

Supporting existing hydro at the expense of new renewable energy. This proposal would provide additional support to existing hydro generation, reducing the amount of new renewable energy generation needed by over 60 per cent, from 25,000 Gigawatt-hours (GWh) to just over 9,000 GWh. This scale of reduction would have a devastating impact on existing market participants, while the flaws in this approach would likely undermine any new investment.

Transfer of $13.5 billion to existing hydro operations. It would lead to a massive wealth transfer to existing hydro generation, at the expense of new renewable energy, worth more than $900 million per year, or $13.5 billion between now and 2030 when the policy ends. Almost 60 per cent of this would flow directly to Tasmania.

Loss of broader economic benefits. The benefits of investment in new large-scale renewable energy would be lost. This includes the $14.5 billion of expected investment and thousands of new jobs in rural and regional parts of Australia.

Loss of carbon abatement benefits. The new investment delivered by the current RET is expected to deliver carbon reductions of 194 megatonnes of carbon by 2030. If the policy was altered as proposed, taxpayers would need to fund additional measures through the Direct Action policy to replace this abatement.

Higher power prices for consumers. A reduction in new electricity supply and competition in the wholesale electricity market would lead to higher power prices for consumers. The benefit of new renewable energy investment on power prices was demonstrated by the ACIL Allen modelling for the recent Warburton Review, which showed that any scenario which led to less renewable energy also led to higher power prices.

Hydro power is already supported by the RET. Hydro is already eligible under the RET, where it generates above a pre-determined baseline. This provides an incentive for the maintenance and upgrade of existing hydro generation, and has provided revenue to Australia’s existing hydro power generators over the life of the policy.

Source: Bretherton, M 2014, 'New Renewable Energy Target proposal would be economic vandalism', Clean Energy Council, 25 Nov, p1, viewed 25 Nov 2014

Posted on:  {{date}}

The Author

Stuart McConaghy

Stuart is a Mechanical Engineer, solar fanantic and co-founder of YourSolarQuotes.com.au.

About Your Solar Quotes

Your Solar Quotes are dedicated to educating Australian homeowners about solar power and the importance of clean and renewable energy. Our mission is to provide all of the information necessary in order to make an informed decision about solar power and to connect homeowners with top rated local solar installers. Our free service enables you to gather all of the information you require about solar power and request quotes in just seconds thanks to our user friendly platform. We take the hassle out of finding quotes from reputable local installers!

about us solar news blog

ENTER YOUR POSTCODE TO RECEIVE YOUR FREE QUOTES

Tell us about your home.

Solar hot water reduces energy usage.

Current hot water system?

What are your best contact details?

Thank you, {{getFirstName()}} we will be in touch shortly!

Share our service to help your friends save!


All Articles

2016/01/15
Home battery storage to augment solar systems in near future
2015/12/24
Clean Energy Fund
2015/12/11
Tesla battery now available in Australia
2015/10/17
Electric Car Recharge Station – Largest in Southern Hemisphere
2015/09/22
The Netherlands to power its railway network on 100% wind energy by 2018
2015/09/09
Solar PV prices to drop by 50% by 2030
2015/09/05
Redflow Zinc Bromide Storage System
2015/08/17
Cochin Airport to be powered by Solar
2015/08/04
Obama unveils ambitious Clean Power Plan to fight Climate Change
2015/07/30
Japan's Kyocera Corporation to develop solar power plants on disused golf courses
2015/07/29
Tesla’s Unveiling of Solar Battery Storage
2015/07/23
Bill Shorten to officially announce 50% Renewable Energy Target by 2030 at ALP Conference
2015/07/17
The Federal Government Jeopardises Renewable Energy Sector Again
2015/07/16
The World's most efficient solar energy system
2015/07/14
Government has offered $150, 000 to Adelaide Businesses to install Solar Panels
2015/07/14
Prime Minister Tony Abbott has worsened the Wind Power conflict
2015/07/13
Origin Energy begin installing solar power system at the Royal Australian Mint
2015/07/09
Ratch Australia to proceed with a proposed Solar Power Project in Collinsville by 2016
2015/07/08
Goldwind to construct huge wind farm in Northern Sydney
2015/07/03
A future for wind in Australia?
2015/07/02
United Nations demands a zero ban on logging and mining in Tasmania's World Heritage Region
2015/06/26
Partners Group pumps $450 million into the Expansion of Ararat Windfarm in Australia
2015/06/26
Government reduces Renewable Energy Target (RET) by 20%
2015/06/24
Urgent message to all Ergon Energy customers
2015/06/23
Government passes a law to slash Renewable Energy Target
2015/06/15
Solar power assisting the relief effort in Nepal; increasing usage in Australian rural areas
2015/05/10
RET debate drawing to a close as Japan surges forward with space solar
2015/05/01
Elon Musk’s Powerwall is going to revolutionise global energy storage
2015/04/11
Tree shaped wind turbines in Paris
2015/04/10
The RET standoff continues
2015/03/13
Flying Solar
2015/03/05
Australian solar developments and global technological advances
2015/02/26
Australia's Largest Solar Farm to be Built in Qld
2015/01/29
Tony Abbott Snubs International Renewable Energy Conference
2015/01/28
Renewable energy pushing forward
2015/01/13
Global Investment Boom in Renewable Energy
2015/01/08
2015: The year to watch
2014/12/23
Tony Abbott to receive solar panels for Christmas
2014/12/13
Australia is a global leader in solar development, but lags in policy
2014/12/12
The Solar Revolution
2014/12/10
Solar panels are now more efficient than ever
2014/11/25
Disgraceful new RET proposal is economic vandalism
2014/11/18
Melbourne show goes green with solar power
2014/10/09
Hybrid Materials could smash the solar efficiency ceiling
2014/10/08
Royal Australian Mint announces commercial solar tender
2014/09/29
The sun could be the world’s largest source of electricity by 2050
2014/08/19
Proposed cuts to Renewable Energy Target completely out of touch
2014/07/28
Solar is creating jobs and slashing bills
2014/07/17
A dark day for Australia as carbon tax is repealed
2014/06/26
Clean Energy Council thank Clive Palmer
2014/06/17
The remarkable energy transition in South Australia
2014/05/06
Australia To Pioneer Off-Grid Solar Power Storage With SunPower
2014/04/03
Apple, Google and Facebook make a change for a greener internet
2014/02/18
RET Review Announced
2014/02/12
Macquarie Bank enters solar finance market in Australia
2014/02/01
Investors Banking on Solar
2014/01/29
Australia Day honours for solar pioneers
2014/01/28
Construction Begins on Nyngan
2014/01/09
Australia now has two million small scale renewable installations
2013/12/09
Australia reaches another solar milestone
2013/12/02
Tasmania aims for 100% renewable energy by 2020
2013/11/13
Queensland has more solar PV installed then 22 countries
2013/10/23
UQ announce Queensland's largest solar panel array
2013/09/27
South Australian feed in tariff closing September 30